Digistars
  • Weblog
  • Wordpress
  • About

Clash of the Titans: Yammer VS SharePoint Social features

11/4/2013

13 Comments

 
Hail thee fellow information worker heroes...

Since the days are getting darker and colder we can definitely say "Winter is coming", a fellow SharePoint Knight and myself sat together on a round table, shared some tales of our battles and glorious victories over some cold ale and firewater of smoke and peat. Unfortunately due to the rules of my fellow Knights lords, I shall not say his name in here but I may tell from the wisdom he shared with me. We shall name him "The mystic black knight." :-)

This time we tell about Yammer VS SharePoint 2013 Social features.

May peace favour your swords fellow heroes.
Question 1: How do you see the role of Social Media in Intranets right now and the near future?

Answer of the "Mystic Black Knight":
ESN (Enterprise Social Networks) will have a growing role in Intranets. Companies will realise, from use cases and success stories, means how they will benefit from the new working culture. Now the start is slower, as only some of the companies are adapting possibilities provided by ESN, since there is a lots of hesitation what the management will allow their employees do with this. Now the role is about distributing knowledge: Links, news, use cases and success stories but soon ESN will have more role with resourcing, brainstorming and sales opportunities. The role will be not just about linking information, but to link knowledge, persons and ideas together and it will take over email as primary communication channel inside corporate networks - or at least reduce email numbers inside company dramatically. In the near future, it is possible for employees comment on sales opportunities and thus affect the company results directly.

Question 2: What are the strengths of Yammer over SharePoint 2013 social features and vice versa?

Answer of the "Mystic Black Knight":
  1. Yammer is about people and topics. Conversations flow and people get connected, and see what are the hot topics in the company. They can choose what to follow and which groups to join. You can easily use Yammer using different devices and participate/stay on touch on company activity. Yammer allows brainstorming in a very freeform way. Yammer is about people.
  2. SharePoint is about structured information. You can utilise SharePoint's features to create a decent ESN, but it will be more structure-oriented. The information in SharePoint is easier to find and you can manage it. Social features are added on top of this methodology. You can mix document/information management with Social in a solid way. It does have some limitations, but it comes with SharePoint license and is already in place without having to learn a new UI and a new Social tool.


Question 3: How would you address the end user adoption for social features in Intranets?

Answer of the "MBK":
It is a classic example. Create the spark of interest and a bunch of Champions who will carry on the message. Training, examples, uses cases and events that will create more interest. And accept the fact, that not everybody will adopt it early. What helps people to adopt ESN are good examples of use, commitment from the management "it is ok to use ESN at work" and Champions who are happy to share information and help newcomers, creating a friendly atmosphere.

Question 4: What do you think is the most benefits for end users using social features in the Intranet?

Answer of the "MBK":
  1. Not reinventing and doing things twice. If somebody in the organization has already done it, why not do it again? When people collaborate using a user friendly channel, they can share what they have done, their expertise and ask for help.
  2. Finding the right people to help you. When experts are active in ESN, people will start to know them. And when you know somebody, you can contact him easily. Searching for skills is important in a big organization. Of course it is sometimes a huge step forward to ask for help. Somebody perhaps know the right expert and will inform him of the discussion.

Question 5: Do you believe social features will make end users more productive?


Answer of the "MBK":
When you combine all the benefits: not reinventing and doing things twice or thrice, finding the right help sooner, getting your questions answered, participating in new opportunities, getting the answer from the ESN even before asking (=searching) and keeping up with what's going on in the company.. The answer is most definitely yes. But it comes with "it depends" also. The company needs to commit for ESN, they need to actively drive for success and to promote ENS engagement. It is about getting people to see the value and it will not happen overnight.  

May we bless and thank the "Mystic Black Knight" for sharing his wisdom.

Strength, SharePoint and Social Networks!

Ser Jussi

Picture
13 Comments
Harold Gardner link
11/4/2013 05:21:19 pm

Seems a key question is finding the right cultural fit for your organization to keep implementation smooth.

Reply
Steffen Bieser link
11/4/2013 05:38:28 pm

Nice game, but the #pinterest share does not work, it gives the message, that the picture would be too small, you myy want to check that :-)

Reply
Octavio
11/5/2013 12:26:06 am

Good informative post, I think that it would be interesting to see a comparison between even more ESN companies, to analyze the pros and cons of each of them, cheers!

Reply
Darren wall
11/5/2013 01:46:13 am

This topic is a little beyond me, however I can see the benefits.

Reply
doruman link
11/5/2013 01:52:44 am

The idea of "questions & answers" article it's not new, but however, the way you put it in here is original and valuable. As is the choice of subjects. Congratulations on your strategy used!

Reply
Nathan Senn link
11/5/2013 06:55:14 am

It wouldn't take much to beat SharePoint never could get it to work right!

Reply
Dimitrios
11/5/2013 07:05:29 am

I always like Sharepoint

Reply
Luminaryvisions
11/5/2013 08:09:51 am

nice blog post

Reply
julio
11/5/2013 02:41:49 pm

Yammer cant be beat for internal communication.

Reply
Chukchansi
11/5/2013 05:41:14 pm

I have yet to use either one. I read the article in mystic black knight voice.

Reply
Ser Jussi
11/5/2013 06:51:26 pm

Thanks for all the comments so far fellow heroes! :-)

Reply
Tyler link
11/5/2013 06:51:40 pm

My understanding of some of this technical talk is that it's a good idea for companies to keep something like an active online forum where people can have discussions recorded and saved for future benefits. I agree that they can be extremely beneficial!

Reply
Mithu Hassan link
11/9/2013 12:02:37 am

Very nice blog post !!

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    RSS Feed

    Categories

    All
    Augmented Reality
    Big Data
    Change Process
    Chore
    Collaboration
    Cyberpeddling
    Edgelands
    Enterprise 3.0
    Experiences
    Facebook
    Games
    Gamification
    Habit Changing
    Human Resources
    Infographics
    Metadata
    Music
    Od
    Organizational Development
    Outside
    People
    Places
    Productivity
    Report
    Search
    Serious Gaming
    Sharepoint
    Social Gateways
    Social Insiders
    Social Media
    Social Outsiders
    Statistics
    Time
    Top Social Connectors
    Transition
    Video
    Visualization
    Walking
    Wolfram Alpha
    Yammer

Privacy Policy
digistars